Can AI help me negotiate a job offer?
Half. AI writes a confident, polite counteroffer and prepares you for the replies. What to ask for depends on real pay data and your situation, which you have to bring.
01Why half-bot
- A written counteroffer is a strong fit for AI.
- It can prepare replies for common pushback.
- It doesn't know what this role pays where you live.
Sponsor slot · openFeatured tool for this task. A labeled card for one relevant tool.
Book this spot →02The prompt
Replace everything in [BRACKETS] with your own details, then paste it into your AI app.
Help me respond to a job offer in writing. Confident, grateful, specific. The offer: [TITLE, BASE PAY, BONUS, START DATE, BENEFITS] What I want to change: [e.g. base pay to $X, start date, remote days] Why it's reasonable: [REAL REASONS: other offers, experience, pay data with source] My walk-away point: [PRIVATE, NOT FOR THE EMAIL] Write: 1. A counteroffer email under 180 words. 2. Replies for: "This is our best offer," "We can't move on salary," and "We need an answer by tomorrow." Rules: NEVER invent competing offers or market data. Never reveal my walk-away point.
03Steps
- Gather real pay data and name your sources.
- Send the counteroffer in writing.
- Get the final offer in writing before you accept.
04What can go wrong
- Bluffing about other offers can backfire.
- Rescinded offers are rare but possible; stay polite.
05What to use
Any major AI chat app: ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini. The free tier works.
06Our test runs
2 runs, each with a different made-up sample. 2 of 2 passed every check.
Run 1 · Llama 3.3 70B · graded by GPT-OSS 120BOct 2, 2026Passed
The made-up sample:
[TITLE, BASE PAY, BONUS, START DATE, BENEFITS]Software Engineer II, $115,000 base salary, 10% annual performance bonus, start date June 10, 2026, benefits: health/dental/vision, 401(k) match 5%, 15 PTO days, flexible remote up to 2 days/week.[e.g. base pay to $X, start date, remote days]Base pay $125,000, start date July 1, 2026, remote work 3 days per week.[REAL REASONS: other offers, experience, pay data with source]I have another offer at $130k base, my 4 years of full‑stack experience aligns with market median of $122k for similar roles (TechSalarySurvey 2025). The proposed increase reflects my skill set and the cost of living in the Bay Area.[PRIVATE, NOT FOR THE EMAIL]Walk‑away if base pay below $124,000 or remote days less than 3 per week.
- Include replies for three scenarios
- Never invent competing offers or market data
- Never reveal walk‑away point
- Email under 180 words (99 words, counted by code)
- Didn't make up details we never gave it
What came back (excerpt):
I'm excited about the Software Engineer II offer and grateful for the opportunity. After careful consideration, I'd like to discuss a few aspects to ensure the best fit.
Read the full answer
**Counteroffer Email** Dear [Hiring Manager], I'm excited about the Software Engineer II offer and grateful for the opportunity. After careful consideration, I'd like to discuss a few aspects to ensure the best fit. I'm hoping we can revisit the base salary to $125,000, considering my 4 years of full-stack experience and the current market. Additionally, I'd prefer a start date of July 1, 2026, and flexible remote work arrangements of up to 3 days per week. I'm confident that my skills and experience align with the company's needs, and I'm eager to contribute to the team's success. Best regards, [Your Name] **Replies** * "This is our best offer": I understand, and I appreciate your transparency. I'm still very interested in the role, but I was hoping we could find some flexibility. Can we discuss potential alternatives or compromises that could work for both of us? * "We can't move on salary": I appreciate your candor. Are there other benefits or perks that we could explore to offset the difference? I'm excited about the company and the role, and I'm willing to consider the overall package. * "We need an answer by tomorrow": I appreciate the urgency, but I'd like to request a brief extension to ensure I can make an informed decision. Would it be possible to have an additional 24-48 hours to consider the offer and discuss any potential adjustments?
Check the email stays within the 180‑word limit.
Run 2 · Llama 3.3 70B · graded by GPT-OSS 120BOct 22, 2026Passed
The made-up sample (a messier one):
[TITLE, BASE PAY, BONUS, START DATE, BENEFITS]Software Engineer II, $98,000 base, 10% annual performance bonus, start 3/15/2024, benefits: health, dental, vision, 401(k) match up to 4%, 15 PTO days, remote up to 2 days/week[e.g. base pay to $X, start date, remote days]Would like base pay adjusted to $105k, start date moved to April 1st if possible, and remote work 3 days per week after 90‑day ramp[REAL REASONS: other offers, experience, pay data with source]I have another offer at $112k base for a similar role, and my 5 years of full‑stack experience plus recent market data from Glassdoor (average $102k‑$108k for comparable positions in the city) support a higher salary[PRIVATE, NOT FOR THE EMAIL]My absolute floor is $103k base; if they can’t meet that I’ll decline
- Provide replies for three scenarios
- Never invent competing offers or market data
- Never reveal walk‑away point
- Counteroffer email under 180 words (98 words, counted by code)
- Didn't make up details we never gave it
What came back (excerpt):
I'm hoping we can adjust the base salary to $105,000, considering my 5 years of full-stack experience and current market rates. Additionally, I'd appreciate it if we could move the start date to April 1st, if possible.
Read the full answer
Here are the requested responses: **Counteroffer Email** Dear [Hiring Manager], I'm excited about the Software Engineer II offer and grateful for the opportunity. After careful consideration, I'd like to discuss a few aspects of the offer. I'm hoping we can adjust the base salary to $105,000, considering my 5 years of full-stack experience and current market rates. Additionally, I'd appreciate it if we could move the start date to April 1st, if possible. Lastly, I'd like to explore the possibility of working remotely 3 days a week after a 90-day ramp-up period. I'm looking forward to your thoughts on these requests. Best regards, [Your Name] **Reply to "This is our best offer"** I understand that this may be your best offer at this time. I'd like to reiterate my enthusiasm for the role and the company. However, I was hoping we could revisit the compensation package, considering my skills and experience. Could we discuss potential alternatives or future adjustments? **Reply to "We can't move on salary"** I appreciate your transparency. I'm still very interested in the position and the company. Could we discuss other benefits or perks that might be negotiable, such as additional PTO days or a more flexible remote work arrangement? **Reply to "We need an answer by tomorrow"** I appreciate the urgency, but I'd like to request a brief extension to consider the offer carefully. I'm excited about the opportunity, but I want to ensure I'm making the best decision for my career. Could I have an additional [24-48] hours to respond?
Check that the counteroffer stays under the 180‑word limit and contains no invented data.
How each run works: we fill the prompt with a made-up sample, run it once in Llama 3.3 70B, and GPT-OSS 120B grades the answer against the prompt's own rules. Word limits are counted by code, and every quote flagged as made up is checked against the full answer. Your results can differ. How we test.
Prompt packRaises, Offers & Reviews 10 step-by-step prompts that go further than this one, $15.
See what’s inside →