Can AI help me choose between two job offers?

Yes. It compares total compensation, benefits, commute, growth and your own priorities side by side, and shows the math behind the money part.

Verdict: Bot · AI does it well✓ Tested 2 times in Llama 3.3 70B · Oct 26, 2026Written for ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini

Jump to the prompt ↓

Bot

01Why bot

  • Side-by-side comparison with weighted priorities is easy for AI.
  • It turns benefits into dollar estimates you can check.
  • The final call depends on what matters to you.
Sponsor slot · openFeatured tool for this task. A labeled card for one relevant tool.
Book this spot →

02The prompt

Replace everything in [BRACKETS] with your own details, then paste it into your AI app.

prompt.txt
You are a career advisor. This is not financial advice.

Offer A: [SALARY, BONUS, BENEFITS, PTO, COMMUTE, REMOTE]
Offer B: [SAME]
My top 3 priorities: [PRIORITIES]

Your task: compare the offers.

Rules:
- MUST estimate total yearly value for each and show the math, labeling estimates.
- MUST score each offer against my priorities.
- MUST list questions to ask each company before deciding.

Give me: a comparison table, the scores, and the questions.

03Steps

  1. Get both offers in writing.
  2. Run the prompt.
  3. Ask the questions before accepting.

04What can go wrong

  • Benefit values are estimates.
  • Culture and manager matter; talk to people there.

05What to use

Any major AI chat app.

06Our test runs

2 runs, each with a different made-up sample. 1 of 2 passed every check.

Run 1 · Llama 3.3 70B · graded by GPT-OSS 120BOct 4, 2026Passed with a catch

The made-up sample:

  • [SALARY, BONUS, BENEFITS, PTO, COMMUTE, REMOTE]Base salary $95,000. Annual performance bonus up to 12% ($11,400). Benefits: 100% employer‑paid health, dental, vision; 401(k) match 5% after 1 year. PTO 18 days + 7 paid holidays. Commute ~30 min drive, $150/month parking stipend. Remote: 2 days/week remote, 3 days in office.
  • [SAME]Base salary $92,000. Annual bonus up to 15% ($13,800). Benefits: 80% employer‑paid health, dental, vision; 401(k) match 4% immediate. PTO 20 days + 8 paid holidays. Commute ~45 min train, $100/month transit pass. Remote: fully remote with optional coworking stipend $200/month.
  • [PRIORITIES]1) Total compensation (salary, bonus, benefits). 2) Work‑life balance (remote flexibility, PTO). 3) Career growth opportunities (bonus structure, benefits quality, location convenience).
  • Estimate total yearly value with math
  • Label estimates in the calculation
  • Score each offer against the three priorities
  • List questions to ask each company
  • Made up details we never gave it

Details it made up: “$10,000 (Health, Dental, Vision)”, “$4,750 (401(k) match after 1 year)”, “$8,000 (Health, Dental, Vision)”, “$3,680 (401(k) match)”

What came back (excerpt):

ys | 30 min drive | | B | $92,000 | $13,800 | $8,000 (Health, Dental, Vision) + $3,680 (401(k) match) = $11,680 | $92,000 + $13,800 + $11,680 = $117,480 | Fully remote | 20 days + 8 holidays | 45 min train | ### Scoring Against Priorities 1.
Read the full answer
### Comparison Table

| Offer | Base Salary | Annual Bonus (Max) | Benefits Value (Estimate) | Total Yearly Value (Estimate) | Remote Flexibility | PTO | Commute |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| A | $95,000 | $11,400 | $10,000 (Health, Dental, Vision) + $4,750 (401(k) match after 1 year) = $14,750 | $95,000 + $11,400 + $14,750 = $121,150 | 2 days/week remote | 18 days + 7 holidays | 30 min drive |
| B | $92,000 | $13,800 | $8,000 (Health, Dental, Vision) + $3,680 (401(k) match) = $11,680 | $92,000 + $13,800 + $11,680 = $117,480 | Fully remote | 20 days + 8 holidays | 45 min train |

### Scoring Against Priorities

1. **Total Compensation**:
   - Offer A: 8/10 (Higher base salary, but lower bonus percentage compared to Offer B)
   - Offer B: 9/10 (Lower base salary, but higher bonus percentage and immediate 401(k) match)

2. **Work-Life Balance**:
   - Offer A: 7/10 (2 days remote, less PTO compared to Offer B)
   - Offer B: 9/10 (Fully remote, more PTO)

3. **Career Growth Opportunities**:
   - Offer A: 8/10 (Better location for networking, but less flexible remote policy)
   - Offer B: 8/10 (Fully remote might limit in-person networking, but offers more flexibility)

### Questions to Ask Each Company

**For Offer A:**
1. How is the performance bonus structured, and what are the key performance indicators (KPIs) to achieve the maximum bonus?
2. Can the 401(k) match be negotiated to start immediately?
3. Are there opportunities for professional development and career advancement within the company?
4. How does the company culture support work-life balance, especially with the required in-office days?
5. Is there room for negotiation on the remote work policy, potentially increasing the number of remote days?

**For Offer B:**
1. How does the company facilitate networking and professional development opportunities in a fully remote setup?
2. Are there any plans to increase the employer-paid percentage of health, dental, and vision benefits?
3. How does the performance bonus structure work, and what are the expectations for achieving the maximum bonus?
4. Can the company provide more details about the optional coworking stipend and how it can be utilized?
5. How does the company ensure that remote employees feel connected and included in company decisions and activities?

These questions and scores should help in making a more informed decision based on your priorities.

Verify that the benefit monetary estimates are realistic.

Run 2 · Llama 3.3 70B · graded by GPT-OSS 120BOct 26, 2026Passed

The made-up sample (a messier one):

  • [SALARY, BONUS, BENEFITS, PTO, COMMUTE, REMOTE]Offer A: Salary $115k, bonus target 12% (~$13.8k) not guaranteed, benefits health/dental/vision ~$6k, 401k match 4%, PTO 18 days + 2 floating, commute 30‑45 min drive, remote 2 days/week. Offer B: Salary $108k, bonus target 15% (~$16.2k) only if revenue goal met, benefits ~$5.5k, 401k match 5%, PTO 20 days, commute 10‑15 min subway, remote fully.
  • [SAME]Both offers list the same categories (salary, bonus, benefits, PTO, commute, remote) but the actual amounts and policies differ as described.
  • [PRIORITIES]1. Total compensation (salary + bonus + benefits) 2. Work‑life balance (PTO, remote flexibility) 3. Commute time and location
  • Estimate total yearly value with math and labels
  • Score each offer against priorities
  • List questions to ask each company
  • Provide comparison table, scores, and questions
  • Didn't make up details we never gave it

What came back (excerpt):

tal Yearly Value**: - Salary: $108,000 - Bonus: $16,200 (assuming 15% of $108,000) - Benefits: $5,500 - 401k Match (assuming 5% of salary): $5,400 - **Total**: $108,000 + $16,200 + $5,500 + $5,400 = $135,100 ### Scoring Against Priorities 1.
Read the full answer
### Comparison Table

| Category | Offer A | Offer B |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Salary | $115,000 | $108,000 |
| Bonus Target | 12% (~$13,800) | 15% (~$16,200) |
| Benefits | ~$6,000 | ~$5,500 |
| 401k Match | 4% | 5% |
| PTO | 18 days + 2 floating | 20 days |
| Commute | 30-45 min drive | 10-15 min subway |
| Remote Work | 2 days/week | Fully remote |

### Estimated Total Yearly Value

- **Offer A Estimated Total Yearly Value**: 
  - Salary: $115,000
  - Bonus: $13,800 (assuming 12% of $115,000)
  - Benefits: $6,000
  - 401k Match (assuming 4% of salary): $4,600
  - **Total**: $115,000 + $13,800 + $6,000 + $4,600 = $139,400
- **Offer B Estimated Total Yearly Value**:
  - Salary: $108,000
  - Bonus: $16,200 (assuming 15% of $108,000)
  - Benefits: $5,500
  - 401k Match (assuming 5% of salary): $5,400
  - **Total**: $108,000 + $16,200 + $5,500 + $5,400 = $135,100

### Scoring Against Priorities

1. **Total Compensation**:
   - Offer A: $139,400
   - Offer B: $135,100
   - **Score**: Offer A > Offer B

2. **Work-Life Balance**:
   - Offer A: 18 days PTO + 2 floating, remote 2 days/week
   - Offer B: 20 days PTO, fully remote
   - **Score**: Offer B > Offer A (due to fully remote option)

3. **Commute Time and Location**:
   - Offer A: 30-45 min drive
   - Offer B: 10-15 min subway
   - **Score**: Offer B > Offer A

### Questions to Ask Each Company

**For Both Companies:**

1. What are the specific goals or metrics that need to be met to achieve the bonus target?
2. How often are salary and bonus structures reviewed for potential increases?
3. Are there opportunities for professional development or further education support?
4. What is the typical career path for someone in this role, and how have past employees in this role progressed?

**For Offer A:**

1. Is there flexibility in the remote work policy, or are there specific reasons it's limited to 2 days a week?
2. How does the company support work-life balance, given the commute time and less flexible remote policy?
3. Are there any plans to expand benefits or improve the 401k match in the future?

**For Offer B:**

1. What are the revenue goals that need to be met for the bonus target, and how achievable are they based on past performance?
2. How does the company ensure that fully remote work arrangements are successful and that employees feel connected to the team and company culture?
3. Are there any concerns about the impact of being fully remote on career advancement or visibility within the company?

Verify the scores are presented clearly and meet the scoring requirement.

How each run works: we fill the prompt with a made-up sample, run it once in Llama 3.3 70B, and GPT-OSS 120B grades the answer against the prompt's own rules. Word limits are counted by code, and every quote flagged as made up is checked against the full answer. Your results can differ. How we test.

Prompt packRaises, Offers & Reviews 10 step-by-step prompts that go further than this one, $15.
See what’s inside →